AI Query: Please name any books or journals—in Indonesian or English—that provide a comprehensive discussion on the theme of "Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics." Is there any work that covers it fully, or at least comes closest to doing so?
AI
Answer:
Yes.
I have conducted searches using a broad range of keywords—such as Islamic
agricultural economics, Islamic agriculture socioeconomics, Islamic
agribusiness, Islamic agriculture, Islamic food economy, Islamic agricultural
financing, and their Indonesian equivalents—while also tracking relatively
recent books, journals, and publications.
The
main conclusion is quite clear: to date, I have not found any other book or
journal that addresses "Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics"
holistically as a distinct field of study. In fact, your book, published in
2025, appears to be the work that comes closest to serving as a comprehensive
textbook or monograph for this field. (www.slideshare.net)
1. The most comprehensive work: the book
by Syahyuti (2025).
Syahyuti.
2025. Sosial Ekonomi Pertanian Islam: Konsep, Urgensi, dan Praktiknya di
Dunia [Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics: Concepts, Urgency, and Global
Practices]. Bogor: IPB Press. This is not merely a book about "agriculture
according to Islam"; rather, it explicitly attempts to establish a new
scholarly framework.
The
table of contents demonstrates its vast scope: concepts and principles of
Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics; the epistemology of agricultural
socio-economics; the Islamization of agriculture; Islamic Agrarian Reform;
Islamic Organic Agriculture; Islamic Agricultural Financing; Islamic
Agricultural Labor Systems; gender in Islamic agriculture; Islamic supply
chains; Islamic food security; the Islamic food economy; Islamic food systems;
Islamic agricultural extension; Islamic family farming; Islamic food
sovereignty; Islamic agribusiness; Islamic cooperatives; Islamic agricultural
economics; Islamic agriculture; and, ultimately, Islamic Agricultural
Socio-economics. (www.slideshare.net)
The
book even features a dedicated chapter titled “Concepts and Principles of
Islamic Agricultural Socioeconomics,” a chapter on the movement and program for
the Islamization of Agriculture, followed by chapters on “Islamizing Global
Agriculture” and “Islamizing Indonesian Agriculture.” (www.slideshare.net)
The
Ministry of Agriculture Library catalog also lists the book as a monograph:
Syahyuti. Sosial Ekonomi Pertanian Islam: Konsep, Urgensi, dan Praktiknya di
Dunia [Islamic Agricultural Socioeconomics: Concepts, Urgency, and Practice in
the World]. Bogor: IPB Press, 2025; call number 338.43:297 SYA s. (Kikp
Pertanian)
So,
if the question is “which book is the most comprehensive?”—the answer is this
one.
2.
An English version also exists
Syahyuti.
Islamic Agricultural Socioeconomics: Theory, Urgency, and Practice in the World.
In the introduction to the English version, its scope is described as an effort
to bring over 30 years of experience in agricultural socioeconomics into an
Islamic perspective. (Which one is it?)
However,
there is one important caveat: I have not yet seen evidence that the English
version has been published as an English-language academic book by an
international publisher with a bibliographic status equivalent to the 2025 IPB
Press edition. Therefore, for the time being, I will treat it as an English
edition/manuscript rather than an established international book.
3.
Crucially: the 2020 draft was the precursor
Long
before the 2025 book, there was: Syahyuti. 2020. Bertani dan Berdagang Secara
Islami [Farming and Trading in an Islamic Manner]. “Islamic Agricultural
Socioeconomics” Book Series. Draft I, April 2020. This is actually highly
significant in terms of the history of thought. On April 22, 2020, Syahyuti
publicly wrote that he was using the term "Islamic Agricultural
Socio-economics Book Series" (Seri Buku Sosial Ekonomi Pertanian Islam),
noting at the time that he had not yet encountered the phrases "Islamic
Agricultural Economics," "Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics,"
or "Islamic Agriculture Socio-economic" in Google searches.
(Websyahyuti)
The
draft’s content covered: Islam and agriculture; the history of Islamic
civilization's contributions to agriculture; agricultural ethics; land and
water; land leasing; muzara'ah/mukhabarah (sharecropping arrangements); land
pledging; farm labor relations; zakat on agricultural produce; agrarian reform;
trade; and a dedicated chapter on "Islamic Agricultural
Socio-economics." (Websyahyuti)
Thus,
genealogically speaking:
2020
— The concept of "Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics" was
introduced (via Bertani dan Berdagang Secara Islami).
2025
— The concept of Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics was developed into a far
more systematic scholarly framework.
4.
So, what about other books or journals worldwide?
This
is where the research findings become interesting. I discovered a vast amount
of literature discussing various components of Islamic Agricultural
Socio-economics, yet almost nothing that integrated them into a single, unified
field.
A.
Islamic Agribusiness
This
field is already quite well-developed. In Indonesia, there is even the Sharia
Agribusiness Journal, published by UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta. This
journal explicitly covers: agricultural management, economics, technology,
social aspects, halal food, and empowerment through Islamic institutions such
as mosques and pesantren (Islamic boarding schools). Thus, the field is closely
aligned with Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics (UIN Jakarta Journal).
However, its scope remains agribusiness, rather than a general theory of
Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics.
B.
Islamic Agricultural Economics
This
field is also beginning to emerge as a distinct discipline. However, the
literature typically focuses on specific sub-themes: Islamic agricultural
finance, agricultural zakat, waqf for agriculture, muzara'ah, mukhabarah,
farmer welfare, halal food, Islamic agribusiness, and sustainable agriculture.
There
is not yet a single book that integrates economics, social aspects,
institutions, agrarian issues, labor, food, agribusiness, extension services,
and cooperatives.
5.
There is a very closely related journal: Sharia Agribusiness Journal
If
someone is looking for the most relevant journal literature, I would recommend
this one. The Sharia Agribusiness Journal explicitly positions itself at the
intersection of Agriculture, Economics, Management, Social aspects, and Sharia.
The journal has been active since 2021 and is published twice a year (UIN
Jakarta Journal).
However,
it must be noted again: Sharia Agribusiness ≠ Islamic Agricultural
Socio-economics. Sharia Agribusiness is essentially just one branch or
component.
6.
Recent literature indicates that this field is beginning to fragment
This
actually reinforces the argument that there is no truly comprehensive book
other than the one by Syahyuti mentioned above. For example, a 2026 study
titled "Integrating Zakat and Waqf for Sustainable Food Security"
examines the relationship: zakat + waqf → food security → production + social protection + sustainability.
This is highly relevant to Islamic Agricultural Socio-economics, yet it
addresses only a small segment—specifically Islamic social finance and food
security. (Untirta Journal)
Another
study from 2026, “Sustainable Agriculture in Subang: Integrating Local Wisdom,
Sharia Principles, and Agribusiness Innovation,” combines local wisdom, Sharia,
agribusiness, and sustainable agriculture. Yet, once again, it does not
constitute a general theory of Islamic Agricultural Socioeconomics. (eJournal
of Sunan Gunung Djati)
There
is also research titled “Agribusiness Development Model in Sharia-Based
Socio-Economic Planning,” which links Sharia economics, agribusiness, farmer
welfare, and maqashid al-shariah (the objectives of Sharia). (SiduCat). This
indicates that while the constituent elements of the field are emerging, an
overarching academic framework has not yet been established.
7.
So, is there a “comprehensive” book available?
My
answer: I have not yet found one that is truly comprehensive, other than the
book Sosial Ekonomi Pertanian Islam (Islamic Agricultural Socioeconomics) by
Syahyuti.
8.
What I find particularly interesting from an academic standpoint
Following
this inquiry, I would slightly revise our earlier conclusion. It is not merely
that few books address "Islamic Agricultural Socioeconomics."
Going
further: Current global literature appears fragmented into Islamic Finance,
Islamic Agribusiness, Islamic Agriculture, Islamic Food Systems, Islamic Social
Finance, Islamic Agricultural Economics, and so forth—whereas the integration
of these realms into a unified discipline of "Islamic Agricultural
Socioeconomics" has yet to become firmly established.
This
is precisely why the structure of Syahyuti’s (2025) book is epistemologically
strategic: rather than simply appending the word "Islamic" to
"Agricultural Economics," it attempts to position "Islamic
Agricultural Socioeconomics" as a hypernym—an overarching umbrella—for
several new sub-fields. The table of contents explicitly lists 17 concepts,
with "Islamic Agricultural Socio-Economics" designated as the
seventeenth. (www.slideshare.net)
Indeed,
the book’s final chapter explicitly discusses "Islamic Agricultural
Socioeconomics as a discipline," addressing the need for scientific
justification, the field's structural positioning, and future institutional
strategies. (SyahYUTI)
In
other words: Most other books answer the question, "How is Islam applied
to agriculture?" whereas Syahyuti (2025) attempts to pose a broader
question: "Is there a need to establish a discipline that specifically
examines the full spectrum of social, economic, institutional, agrarian, food,
and agribusiness relationships through the lens of an Islamic worldview?"
These are two distinct questions.
And
based on my current research, there appears to be no other book that
comprehensively addresses this second question.
*****
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar